Last updated: June 2026.
Disclosure: Some links in this article are affiliate links. If you purchase through them, SmartPubTools earns a small commission at no extra cost to you. This doesn’t influence our recommendations — all opinions are Shaun’s own, based on running Teal Farm Pub and SmartPubTools.com.
Running this problem at your pub?
Here's the system I use at The Teal Farm to fix it — real-time labour %, cash position, and VAT liability in one dashboard. 30-minute setup. £97 once, no monthly fees.
Get Pub Command Centre — £97 →No monthly fees. 30-day money-back guarantee. Built by a working pub landlord.
The Heineken Factor
Owned by brewing giant Heineken, Star Pubs & Bars has long been one of the UK’s biggest pubcos. But for years, its reputation among landlords was rocky. In 2023, Star scored just 55% satisfaction in the Pubs Code Adjudicator (PCA) survey — one of the lowest in the sector.
Fast forward to 2025, and things look very different. According to the latest PCA survey, landlord satisfaction with Star has jumped to 70%, putting them firmly in the mid-table and closing in on rivals like Greene King (78%).
So, what’s changed? Backed by Heineken’s global resources and a renewed push into franchise-style models, Star is repositioning itself as a serious contender in the pubco market.
This review breaks down:
- The pros and cons of working with Star.
- Landlord experiences from surveys and forums.
- How Star compares to rivals like Admiral, Greene King, Punch, and Stonegate.
- Whether you should consider them in 2025.
Star Pubs by the Numbers (2025–26 Snapshot)
- Ownership: Part of Heineken UK.
- Pubs: ~2,500 across the UK, mix of city, town, and suburban venues.
- Business models: Tenancies, leases, and franchise/retail partnership formats.
- Landlord satisfaction: 70% (PCA 2025 survey) — up 15 points since 2023.
- Trends: Strong refurb programme; shifting toward franchise-style partnerships to attract new operators.
Pros of Working with Star Pubs & Bars
Star’s 2025 turnaround didn’t happen by accident. Backed by Heineken’s resources and a push to modernise their agreements, they’ve carved out a stronger position than just two years ago.
✅ Backed by Heineken
- As part of Heineken UK, Star has the financial muscle and brand clout smaller pubcos can’t match.
- Landlords benefit from:
- Access to Heineken beers (Heineken, Birra Moretti, Amstel, etc.).
- Marketing support tied to Heineken’s global sponsorships (football, rugby, festivals).
- Stronger supply chains and consistent stock compared to independents.
💬 Landlord (PCA survey 2025):
“Star’s Heineken connection means I get beers punters recognise and promotions I could never afford myself.”
✅ Rising Landlord Satisfaction
- From 55% in 2023 → 70% in 2025, Star has made the biggest leap of any pubco in the PCA survey.
- Improvements credited to:
- More responsive BDMs.
- New franchise-style agreements.
- Investment in refurbishments.
✅ Franchise-Style Models
- Star is rolling out more franchise and retail partnership models to attract new landlords.
- These agreements often reduce upfront costs and provide shared risk with Star.
- Popular with newcomers who want structure without massive financial exposure.
✅ Investment in Refurbishments
- Star has committed significant funding to refurb programmes, modernising pubs and helping landlords attract customers.
- Landlords report pubs being in better condition compared to 2–3 years ago.
💬 Landlord, Reddit 2025:
“Star refurbished our place before we took over. It gave us a head start — we walked into a pub already trading well.”
Cons of Working with Star Pubs & Bars
Despite their big jump in satisfaction, Star Pubs & Bars still carries the baggage of being a large, brewer-backed pubco. Landlords highlight several recurring issues.
❌ Strict Beer Ties
- As part of Heineken, Star operates some of the strictest tied agreements in the industry.
- Landlords are required to stock Heineken brands first and foremost.
- While these beers are popular, it limits flexibility for landlords wanting to feature independent or local brews.
💬 Landlord, PCA survey 2025:
“I’d love to put on a couple of local ales, but with Star you’re locked into the Heineken range.”
❌ Pub Closures in Weak Areas
- Star has closed or sold a number of underperforming sites in recent years.
- This has created uncertainty for landlords in borderline-trade pubs.
- Landlords in rural or low-footfall areas feel more at risk.
❌ Still a Corporate Pubco
- While satisfaction is improving, Star remains a large corporate landlord.
- Some landlords report slow responses, rigid rules, and paperwork-heavy processes.
- Compared to Admiral’s “community-first” approach, Star feels more transactional.
❌ Inconsistent BDM Support
- Though survey results are improving, there are still reports of regional inconsistencies.
- Some landlords get proactive, engaged BDMs — others feel left to fend for themselves.
💬 Reddit landlord (2025):
“Better than a few years ago, but your experience depends on your BDM. Mine’s great — my mate’s barely hears from his.”
Landlord Experiences – Voices from the Trade
Star’s 2025 performance in the Pubs Code Adjudicator (PCA) survey shows clear progress, but it’s the voices of landlords that reveal the lived reality of running a Star pub.
PCA Survey 2025 Highlights
- 70% landlord satisfaction (up 15 points since 2023).
- 73% said their BDM treated them fairly.
- 68% praised refurbishments and investment in sites.
- 54% still raised concerns about strict ties and product choice.
Positive Experiences
💬 Landlord, PCA survey 2025:
“Star refurbished the pub before we took over — it meant we started ahead rather than fighting to catch up.”
💬 Reddit landlord (r/pubs):
“The Heineken link helps. Punters know what they’re getting, and the marketing around football really brings people in.”
Negative Experiences
💬 Landlord, X (2025):
“Ties are still the killer. Great refurb, but I can’t put on my local brewer’s beers. Feels restrictive.”
💬 Facebook landlord group comment:
“It’s better than before, but still a big corporate machine. Some things take ages to get sorted.”
Balanced Verdict from the Trade
- Upward trend: Landlords generally agree Star is improving.
- Still corporate: Satisfaction is better, but landlords warn it’s “not Admiral.”
- Best fit: Works well for those who want brewery backing + franchise-style structure, less so for independents who crave freedom.
Comparing Star to Other Pubcos in 2026
Star’s rise from the bottom of the table in 2023 (55% satisfaction) to a respectable 70% in 2025 shows how quickly a pubco’s reputation can change. But how do they stack up against the competition?
Satisfaction Rankings (PCA Survey 2025)
| Pubco | Landlord Satisfaction (2025) | Strengths | Weaknesses |
|---|---|---|---|
| Admiral Taverns | 79% (highest) | Community focus, flexible agreements | Smaller pubs, tied beer |
| Greene King | 78% | Brewery perks, Hive Pub model, brand power | Repairs, corporate rigidity, tied model |
| Star Pubs & Bars | 70% (up from 55%) | Heineken backing, refurb investment | Strict ties, corporate processes |
| Marston’s | 72% | Turnover models, national scale | Supply chain disruption, rigid contracts |
| Punch Taverns | 61% | Flexible entry, refurb investments | Rent hikes, stock markups |
| Stonegate | 43% (lowest) | Marketing muscle, retail partnerships | Poor support, high churn, rent disputes |
Key Takeaways
- Star vs Admiral (79%) → Admiral still leads with its community-first ethos, but Star is closing the gap.
- Star vs Greene King (78%) → Greene King is steadier and more structured; Star is more about franchise innovation.
- Star vs Punch (61%) & Stonegate (43%) → Star is clearly in a stronger position, distancing itself from the lowest-rated pubcos.
- Trend: If Star keeps improving at this pace, they could break into the top tier by 2026.
💬 Landlord, PCA survey 2025:
“Star isn’t Admiral, but it’s not Stonegate either. They’re climbing, and that’s good for the trade.”
Should You Consider Star Pubs & Bars in 2025?
Star isn’t the landlord’s dream (Admiral) or the landlord’s nightmare (Stonegate). Instead, it’s a pubco on the rise — making big improvements, but still carrying corporate strings.
When Star Might Be Right for You
- ✅ You want the backing of Heineken — marketing muscle, global beer brands, and supply stability.
- ✅ You’re open to franchise-style agreements with structured support.
- ✅ You’re starting out and want a pubco that’s actively improving landlord satisfaction.
- ✅ You’re taking on a pub with planned refurb investment.
💬 Landlord, PCA survey 2025:
“Star refurbished the pub before we opened. It felt like a fresh start — not a tired boozer we had to fix ourselves.”
When to Think Twice
- ❌ You want freedom on beer choice — Star’s Heineken ties are strict.
- ❌ You prefer a community-first, flexible pubco like Admiral.
- ❌ You’re wary of big corporate processes and slower responses.
💬 Landlord, Reddit 2025:
“Better than before, but still a big corporate. Some decisions feel like they come from Amsterdam, not the local high street.”
Final Verdict – A Pubco on the Mend
With 70% landlord satisfaction in 2025, Star has staged one of the most significant turnarounds in the pubco sector. Backed by Heineken’s resources, they’re investing in refurbishments, rolling out franchise-style models, and improving support.
But strict beer ties and a corporate feel mean they won’t suit everyone. Compared to Admiral (79%) and Greene King (78%), Star still lags slightly behind. Compared to Punch (61%) and Stonegate (43%), they look like a far safer bet.
👉 In short: Star Pubs & Bars are no longer at the bottom of the pile. They’re an improving, mid-table pubco worth considering if you value brand backing and refurb investment.
💡 And remember: whichever pubco you go with, your pub only thrives if customers walk through the door. That’s where SmartPubTools.net helps — automating your social posts, event promos, and match-day ads so you spend more time behind the bar and less behind a laptop.
📊 Your EPOS tells you what sold. Pub Command Centre tells you whether you made money.
Real-time labour %, cash position and VAT liability in one dashboard. Built by a working pub landlord. £97 once, no monthly fees. 30-day money-back guarantee.
Get Pub Command Centre — £97 →FAQs – Star Pubs & Bars 2025
Q: Is Star Pubs & Bars a good pub company?
A: In 2025, Star scored 70% satisfaction, up from 55% in 2023. Landlords report better refurb investment and support, but ties remain strict.
Q: Are Star pubs tied?
A: Yes. As part of Heineken, Star pubs are tied to Heineken beers first, limiting flexibility.
Q: What are the main pros of Star?
A: Heineken backing, refurb programmes, franchise models, rising satisfaction.
Q: What are the downsides?
A: Strict beer ties, closures in weaker areas, corporate processes, patchy BDM support.
Q: How does Star compare to Admiral, Greene King, and Stonegate?
A: Admiral (79%) and Greene King (78%) rank higher; Star (70%) is improving but still mid-table; Stonegate (43%) trails far behind.
Operators who want to track pub GP% in real time can see how it’s done at Teal Farm Pub (180 covers, NE38, labour at 15%).
Star Pubs & Bars 2026: More Questions Answered
Is Star Pubs & Bars owned by Heineken?
Yes. Star Pubs & Bars is Heineken UK’s leased and tenanted pub division, which is why its tied range centres on Heineken brands such as Heineken, Birra Moretti and Amstel, backed by Heineken’s marketing and supply chain.
Are Star pubs tied, and how strict is the tie?
Most Star pubs are tied, and the tie is among the stricter in the sector because you’re required to stock Heineken brands first. That limits flexibility on local and craft beer — the most common complaint from Star tenants — though Market Rent Only rights still apply under the Pubs Code.
Is Star Pubs & Bars getting better for landlords?
The trend is up: landlord satisfaction rose from about 55% in 2023 to roughly 70% in the latest PCA survey, driven by refurbishment investment and franchise-style agreements. It still sits behind Admiral and Greene King, but well ahead of Stonegate.
Related guides
Compare the field with our Admiral Taverns review and Stonegate review, and understand your rights at renewal with the Market Rent Only (MRO) guide.
Running your pub on gut feel?
The Pub Command Centre gives you wet GP%, cellar checks, staff cost and weekly P&L — from your phone, every shift. £97 once. No subscription.
See the Pub Command Centre →