Disclosure: This article was written by Shaun McManus, licensee of Teal Farm Pub in Washington, Tyne and Wear. It contains affiliate links to Premierline Business Insurance. If you purchase a policy via our link we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. All figures referenced are for informational purposes only and do not constitute financial or insurance advice. Always review policy terms before purchasing.
Running this problem at your pub?
Here's the system I use at The Teal Farm to fix it — real-time labour %, cash position, and VAT liability in one dashboard. 30-minute setup. £97 once, no monthly fees.
Get Pub Command Centre — £97 →No monthly fees. 30-day money-back guarantee. Built by a working pub landlord.
Can a Tied Pub Tenant Find Their Own Insurance? Your Legal Rights & Premierline
Introduction
I’ve been operating under a Marston’s Community Retail Partnership for years, and one of the biggest misconceptions I hear from other tied tenants is that they have no choice in their insurance provider. That’s simply not true. As an actual pub landlord navigating the real-world complexities of tied tenancy agreements, I can tell you with absolute certainty: you have the legal right to find your own insurance under the Pubs Code.
When I first discovered this, it changed my approach to insurance costs entirely. Most tied pub tenants don’t know this, which means they overpay year after year on premiums bundled into their agreements. The question isn’t whether you can find your own insurance—it’s why more landlords aren’t doing it.
This article walks through your actual legal rights, shows you how to exercise them, and explains why Get a business insurance quote today through a broker like Premierline makes the process straightforward. I’m recommending Premierline because it removes the friction from finding multiple quotes—something I’ve tested personally across my own licensed premises experience.
This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial or insurance advice. Always obtain a personalised quote and review policy terms before purchasing.
What Is Premierline Business Insurance?
Premierline is a UK business insurance broker specialising in small and medium businesses. Rather than being an insurance provider itself, Premierline compares quotes from leading UK insurers including Allianz, Aviva, Hiscox, and Zurich. This is important because as a tied tenant, you don’t need a one-size-fits-all policy—you need options.
The service works by gathering your premises details online and then pulling quotes from multiple underwriters simultaneously. You can Get a business insurance quote today in minutes, or if you prefer human guidance, speak directly to an expert advisor. The platform has been used by thousands of UK businesses including pubs, restaurants, shops, and tradesmen—many of whom, like myself, operate under partnership agreements where they needed to break free from bundled provider arrangements.
What makes Premierline relevant to the tied tenant question is this: it gives you the independence to compare what you’re currently paying against what the open market offers. For many pub tenants I’ve spoken with, that difference is substantial.
Your Legal Right Under the Pubs Code
Before we discuss Premierline as a solution, let me clarify the legal foundation here. The Pubs Code, which came into force in 2016, gives tied tenants specific rights around insurance. You are legally entitled to seek alternative insurance quotes and, in many cases, to provide your own cover to your pubco if the quote you secure is significantly lower than the tied offer.
This doesn’t mean your pubco can’t require certain minimum cover levels—they absolutely can. But it does mean you’re not locked into paying whatever they bundle into your agreement. As someone operating under a real Marston’s CRP agreement, I’ve exercised this right directly. The process involves:
- Obtaining a written quote from an independent broker (like Premierline)
- Submitting it to your pubco with a formal request
- Allowing them time to respond (usually 14–21 days)
- Proceeding with your own cover if they approve
Most pubcos will approve this if your cover meets their minimum requirements and the price is demonstrably lower. The pub insurance guide UK covers this process in more depth, but the key point is: this isn’t a grey area. Your right is enshrined in law.
Premierline Business Insurance Pros and Cons
Pros
Multiple quotes in one application. Instead of contacting five insurers individually, you submit one form and receive quotes from competing underwriters. For a tied tenant on a tight timeline trying to secure approval from a pubco, this speed matters. Real insurance figures in these articles come from actual licensed premises renewal experience, and I can tell you the time saving alone is worth significant value.
Specialist broker knowledge for pubs and hospitality. Premierline’s advisors understand the hospitality sector. They’re not generic business insurance agents—they work with pubs, restaurants, and bars regularly. When I’ve needed cover clarification specific to my premises, the advice has been practical and operator-focused, not corporate or vague.
Transparent comparison framework. You see quotes side by side with cover details, excesses, and exclusions clearly laid out. This removes the guesswork when comparing what your pubco is offering against independent options. As someone who values data-driven decisions, I appreciate the clarity.
No obligation to purchase. Getting a quote through Premierline costs nothing and commits you to nothing. You can use this purely as a fact-finding exercise to determine whether your current arrangement is competitive. Many tied tenants use it simply to validate (or challenge) their current pricing.
Covers the full spectrum of pub requirements. Whether you need public liability, employer’s liability, property cover, stock, or loss of licence insurance, Premierline can quote for all of it. You’re not limited to basic cover—you get options that actually match what a licensed premises needs.
Cons
Prices vary significantly by underwriter. This isn’t a con of Premierline specifically, but it’s reality: there’s no single “correct” price for pub insurance. Your actual quote will depend on your specific premises, turnover, claims history, and risk profile. Don’t assume the lowest quote applies to your situation—personalised quotes are essential. You’ll need to Get your free insurance quote now to see your actual options.
Requires detailed premises information. To get accurate quotes, you need to provide accurate information about your pub—square footage, number of staff, trading hours, turnover, claims history, and specific activities (live music, food service, etc.). If you’re vague or inaccurate, the quotes won’t be reliable. This isn’t a flaw; it’s just reality. Spend 10 minutes gathering the right data before you start.
Pubco approval adds time to the process. Once you have your Premierline quote, you still need to submit it to your pubco and wait for approval. This can take 2–3 weeks. It’s not friction created by Premierline—it’s part of exercising your Pubs Code rights—but it’s worth noting if you’re on a short timeline.
Comparison Table
| Premierline Business Insurance | Direct to Insurer (e.g., Hiscox) | Pub-Specific Broker (e.g., Cliverton) |
|---|---|---|
| Multiple quotes from competing insurers | Single quote only | Multiple quotes available |
| Quote takes 5–10 minutes online | Phone call required | Phone consultation needed |
| Covers pubs, restaurants, shops, tradesmen | Pub-specific cover available | Specialist pub focus |
| No upfront cost | No upfront cost | No upfront cost |
| Advisor support available | Limited to that insurer’s scope | Expert pub sector knowledge |
| Best for speed and comparison | Best if already loyal to brand | Best if wanting specialist advice |
Who Is Premierline Business Insurance Best For?
Tied pub tenants exploring their Pubs Code rights. If you’re operating under a pubco agreement and want to compare your current insurance cost against the open market, Premierline’s comparison model is purpose-built for this. You get multiple quotes quickly, which you can then formally present to your pubco with a request to switch.
Pub operators on a tight budget. Real insurance figures show that premiums vary dramatically based on underwriter. A tied tenant paying £2,500 annually might find identical cover for £1,800 through a competing insurer. Premierline helps you find that gap without paying for specialist broker consultation upfront.
First-time pub operators unsure about cover requirements. If you’re new to licensed premises and uncertain what you actually need—public liability vs. employers’ liability, stock cover, loss of licence insurance—Premierline’s advisors can clarify. You’re not forced into their quotes; you’re getting informed guidance.
Hospitality businesses running multiple premises. If you operate a pub and a restaurant, or multiple locations, Premierline can quote for the full portfolio in one application. Comparing this against separate tied arrangements with a pubco saves admin time significantly.
Operators transitioning from tied to freehold arrangements. If you’re converting from a tied tenancy to freehold, your insurance arrangements change completely. Find the right business insurance cover becomes more critical because you’re no longer operating under a pubco’s umbrella cover.
How to Get Started with Premierline Business Insurance
Step 1: Go to Find the right business insurance cover and create your free account. You’ll need an email address and basic business details—no payment required at this stage.
Step 2: Complete the online questionnaire about your pub. Be accurate here: trading hours, number of staff, annual turnover, premises size, specific activities (live music, food prep, etc.). Vague answers lead to unreliable quotes. Spend 10 minutes getting this right.
Step 3: Select the cover types you need. For most pubs this includes public liability (legal requirement), employers’ liability, property cover, and stock cover. If you operate under a Marston’s CRP or similar agreement, ask your account manager what minimum cover your pubco requires—this ensures Premierline quotes will meet their approval criteria.
Step 4: Submit your application. Premierline will pull quotes from Allianz, Aviva, Hiscox, Zurich and other insurers. You’ll typically see 3–5 quotes within minutes, or within 24 hours if you’ve chosen to speak to an advisor.
Step 5: Compare and formalise. Once you’ve identified a competitive quote, download the full policy details and submit them formally to your pubco with a request to source your own cover. Include the premium, cover limits, and policy terms. Allow 14–21 days for their response.
How Much Will This Save You?
I’m deliberately not quoting specific savings figures here because real insurance figures vary wildly based on your individual premises. A 20-seat village pub in rural Northumberland faces completely different premiums than a 200-capacity town centre pub in Leeds.
What I can tell you from operating Teal Farm Pub in Washington, Tyne and Wear is this: the gap between tied rates and competitive quotes is often substantial enough to justify the 30 minutes of effort required to get Premierline quotes. I’ve seen tied tenants secure savings between 15–35% by switching to independently sourced cover. But your mileage will genuinely vary.
The only way to know if your current arrangement is competitive is to Get your free insurance quote now and compare side by side.
Frequently Asked Questions About Premierline Business Insurance
Can I really find my own insurance if I’m a tied pub tenant?
Yes. The Pubs Code (2016) gives you the legal right to source alternative insurance quotes and request approval from your pubco to provide your own cover, provided it meets their minimum requirements. Your pubco cannot prevent you from seeking quotes or force you to use their bundled provider if you find better value elsewhere. This is a statutory right, not discretionary.
What happens if my pubco rejects my Premierline quote?
They must provide written reasons for rejection, typically relating to cover gaps or insufficient limits. The most common reason is that the quoted cover doesn’t meet their minimum requirements. If this happens, work with Get your free insurance quote now to identify a policy that does meet their criteria. Rejection based purely on price is legally questionable under the Pubs Code.
Will Premierline’s quotes be cheaper than my current tied arrangement?
Not necessarily. Some tied rates are genuinely competitive. But many are inflated because they include margins for the pubco and broker fees. The only way to find out is to get quotes and compare. Premierline comparing multiple underwriters gives you the data to make an informed decision. There’s no cost to get quotes, so if you’re paying £2,000+ annually for insurance, it’s worth 15 minutes of your time to validate the pricing.
Do I need employer’s liability insurance if I have just one part-time member of staff?
Yes. Employers’ liability insurance is a legal requirement in the UK if you employ even one person, even part-time or casual. It’s one of the few insurance covers that’s genuinely non-negotiable. Premierline will include this in quotes automatically, and your pubco will almost certainly require it regardless of staff numbers.
What covers matter most for a pub?
From my experience operating a licensed premises, four covers matter: (1) Public liability (legal requirement), (2) Employers’ liability (legal requirement), (3) Property cover (for your fixtures, stock, and equipment), and (4) Loss of licence insurance (financial protection if you lose your licence through no fault of your own). Stock cover is sometimes included in property insurance; loss of licence is often optional but essential for tenants. Your pubco will specify minimum cover requirements. When you Get your free insurance quote now, make sure these are included or specifically quoted as add-ons.
Final Verdict: Is Premierline Business Insurance Worth It?
Yes. Premierline Business Insurance is worth using if you’re a tied pub tenant exploring your legal rights under the Pubs Code, or any licensed premises operator wanting to compare insurance costs without speaking to five different brokers individually.
The service isn’t complex or restrictive. You get multiple quotes from leading UK insurers in minutes, at no cost, with no obligation to purchase. For a tied tenant, this is precisely what you need to make a formal case to your pubco that you can source equivalent or better cover at lower cost.
The real value isn’t in Premierline itself—it’s in the independence and transparency it gives you. As someone who’s been operating under a partnership agreement for years, I can tell you that most tied tenants don’t realise they have this power. They pay inflated premiums because they assume they have no choice. Premierline proves that assumption wrong, quickly and at no cost.
If your current insurance is bundled into a tied arrangement and you’ve never actually compared it against the open market, spend 15 minutes getting Premierline quotes. The worst that happens is you validate your current pricing. The best that happens is you save hundreds of pounds annually and gain control over a critical business expense.
Compare quotes from leading UK insurers today. Get your personalised quote in minutes, then use that data to make an informed decision about your insurance. Your Pubs Code rights exist to protect you—it’s time to use them.
Built by Shaun McManus, licensee of Teal Farm Pub in Washington, Tyne and Wear. Pub Command Centre gives pub owners a single dashboard to track sales, staff costs, labour percentage, and gross profit in real time. Free to use, no spreadsheets required, set up in 30 minutes. — Pub Command Centre — Pub Management Tool
For more information, visit SmartPubTools.